Woman Loses Suit Against Driver Who Braked After Chicken Crossed Road, Ordered To Pay S$15,000

A woman who sued her private-hire driver over injuries she claimed resulted from sudden braking has lost her case and was ordered to pay S$15,000 in legal costs.

The driver had braked to avoid hitting a vehicle ahead, which had itself braked after a chicken crossed its path.

District Judge Jonathan Ng Pang Ern found that the driver was not negligent. His written grounds were published on 18 November 2026.

ADVERTISEMENT

Passenger Challenged Following Distance And Braking

Ms Yvonne Chen Qianyun was travelling along Holland Road in Mr Tan Teng Kiat’s private-hire vehicle on 19 February 2024.

She alleged that he followed the vehicle ahead too closely, forcing him to stop abruptly. Alternatively, she argued that he braked harder than reasonably necessary.

Mr Tan said he had enough space and time to brake. He estimated his speed at about 50kmh and his following distance at around 10m. There was no collision.

Judge Found Emergency Braking Was Reasonable

The judge found that Mr Tan had probably applied an emergency or hard brake, despite his account that he had braked normally.

ADVERTISEMENT

However, given how quickly events unfolded, emergency braking would have been reasonable regardless of whether he maintained an adequate following distance.

Whether the braking caused her claimed injuries was not an issue being decided at this trial.

ADVERTISEMENT

“In an imperfect world, some losses must lie where they fall,” he wrote.

The costs order also includes any applicable GST and reasonable case expenses.

Ms Chen has filed an appeal to the General Division of the High Court.

Read Also:  Two Women Due in Court Over Alleged Interference With NParks Crow Traps